Skip to content

The problem with purists and cert junkies

Blog
  • I’ve never classed myself as or behaved like a technology purist. In fact, quite the opposite. Don’t get me wrong - I’m no maverick but I’ve never been a fan of opening a Microsoft exam prep guide and quoting sections of it to state my case. No. I prefer to leverage my own experience - knowledge that has been acquired over 30 years and earned “in the trenches”. In most cases, doing things “by the book” from a technology standpoint is nothing more than taking a much longer route to solve an issue, and in some cases, a recipe for disaster - rather like setting yourself up for a fall.

    If we religiously “follow the yellow brick road” in terms of technology, there’s nothing unique about the approaches we take to quickly and effectively resolve an issue, nor are there any specific skills that set an individual apart from everyone else - in actual fact, we would all be carbon copies of each other so there would never be any variety - or more than one way to resolve a specific issue. Purists need to understand that just because a particular resolution works in a classroom, it’s by no means any indication that it will work in the real world.

    And then, there’s the certification debate. Let’s get this clear from the start. I’m not bashing anyone with certifications - if you genuinely believe one week in a cla*sroom, cram seasons, brain dumps, then an exam will outweigh years of practical and demonstrable experience, then that’s great. It’s just that I will never share this view.

    Take this Dilbert cartoon - it’s an old favourite of mine and basically says it all in three slides.

    dt000831.gif

    What follows is my own personal experience of the certification mill. Back in the early 00’s, I worked for a commodities and trading firm, where I held a third line support post (for those wondering what “third line” means, this site offers an excellent explanation. In addition, their definition of third line support absolutely nails the very same message I conveyed above around experience and knowledge)

    They’re more technically trained, experienced, and knowledgeable.

    This sums up the third line position perfectly. You might get knowledge from cla*srooms, but experience is gained “in the trenches”. And that same “knowledge” is often useless in real-world scenarios.

    We were in the process of building a web server that would house an “emergency folder” of all numbers and contacts you could use, and who you should notify in the event that something went wrong. This formed the basis of an early type of “run book” which means the same thing, but probably better understood in the industry (the firm I was working for was Swiss). The technical hierarchy of this firm was bizarre to say the least. The head office was based in Zug, Switzerland, and was considered to be the location where “the specialists” in subject matter were.

    In all honesty, this could not have been further from the truth (their opinion was taken for “gospel” over yours every time regardless of if they were right or wrong!), although that was their policy, and they were sticking by it. One individual there was a certification “junkie” - I use that term because he systematically attended class after class, did the revision, and sat the exam afterwards. Not that there’s anything “wrong” with this particular approach - but this meant that if a solution to an issue wasn’t in any Microsoft textbook, or part of any course, it wasn’t valid in his view.

    The upshot of the issue was that I wanted to force a specific DNS name - in this case it would have been simple initials - “LEF”, which would have stood for “London Emergency Folder” and when entered into the browser, the web server would serve the correct site. The individual in question tried to tell me that it wasn’t possible to do this - to which I responded it was in fact possible with the use of headers - which have been around since IIS 4.0 and Windows NT. I was going to demonstrate how this would work, although he said he didn’t have time, and needed to go to a meeting.

    Fair enough - apart from the fact that 5 minutes later, I received an email from him that simply had the subject for your information with the message body being I did do the iis 4 exam.

    I’ll admit, I was pretty p***ed by this response. Basically, just because he didn’t come across it in the coursework, or the exam, it wasn’t possible. And the response itself? In my view, it’s just plain dismissive, and rude. Just because he’d done the exam, his knowledge is superior. I don’t think so.

    According to this site - dated 13th August 2001, so not my imagination 🙂

    https://www.itprotoday.com/cloud-computing/run-multiple-sites-your-iis-server

    This is absolutely possible. And I’d read this article a few months before tackling this specific issue.

    That same article was authored by Mark Minasi (a very well-known and equally respected author) - see Mark Minasi - Windows Server Author | Pluralsight

    https://www.pluralsight.com/authors/mark-minasi

    And the moral of this story? Just because you have been in a clasroom environment and become certified, it does not make you an expert. Experience will always masively outweigh certifications in my view, and proof of concept is all the evidence you will ever need.

  • “Take this Dilbert cartoon - it’s an old favorite of mine and basically says it all in three slides.”

    Im here for the Dilbert cartoon … cant see it?

  • @Panda Sorry - it’ll be there now. I am also using a “curse words” plugin that looks for a**, but also blocks “assets” - not very well written sadly…


Related Topics
  • Why Forums Are Still Relevant in 2024

    Blog
    3
    2 Votes
    3 Posts
    112 Views

    @JAC wow. Thanks for the great comments. They are truly appreciated.

    I tend to agree with the social media comments you’ve made. This is made all the more prominent in relation to recent events in Southport for example, and toxicity is a huge issue. Just look at some of the comments from trolls - they are truly disgusting, and the perpetrators seem to take great delight in the anonymity the Internet affords them.

    forums in general are much more subject focused, easier to moderate and users are less likely to be banned because they are there for a specific interest or reason, not to cause trouble.

    Agreed, although discussions can still get out of hand and quite often, these are left to run riot and quickly spiral out of control. A great example of that is here

    https://sudonix.org/topic/141/how-to-destroy-a-community-before-it-s-even-built

    there’s something much more calming about coming to a specific page at your fancy, posting and taking part in healthy debates over the real mishmash of social media.

    Yes, I personally prefer the atmosphere of a forum against the backdrop of unwanted noise via social media.

  • 2 Votes
    2 Posts
    156 Views

    This is worth listening to

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct5wmc

  • 3 Votes
    4 Posts
    226 Views

    @phenomlab yeah you have a good point there. Information over lives just doesn’t seem to be worth it. And being the one to release that info and be the one who first put it out there, you may be on the right track about the notoriety.

  • 0 Votes
    2 Posts
    382 Views

    See enclosed article from Sky News

    https://news.sky.com/story/worlds-largest-botnet-taken-down-as-alleged-chinese-mastermind-arrested-and-29m-in-cryptocurrency-seized-13145394

  • Recall to take screenshots every 2 seconds

    Blog
    13
    9 Votes
    13 Posts
    436 Views

    @phenomlab said in Recall to take screenshots every 2 seconds:

    Not that it matters to me - my laptop runs KDE Neon

    That is a really nice distro.

  • 3 Votes
    3 Posts
    382 Views

    @crazycells if it does indeed materialise, then this could well be a landmark case that sets a precedent. But, I don’t hold much hope to be honest. I’d like to be wrong.

  • Goodbye OnePlus, hello Samsung

    Blog
    44
    29 Votes
    44 Posts
    1k Views

    @Madchatthew definitely. Also good for the environment as it reduces landfill.

  • 1 Votes
    3 Posts
    434 Views

    @downpw I’m inclined to agree with the self-development - and the point you make about the lack of certification being seen as a barrier to enter professions.

    @downpw said in Experience vs Certification - who wins?:

    Because even without experience, if you have an iron will, you can be better than someone who has certification. With more work and effort, certainly, but does it matter?

    This is an interesting statement because I knew of several people years ago whom obtained MCSE accreditation, but had never sat in front of a real-life scenario before where they had to fix something - hence, the term, “Paper MCSE”. Essentially, this involves reading a book, then going to do the exam. Some people have that capability where they can retain a bulk load of information, and use that to easily pass an exam - yet have no practical experience.

    To me, it’s easy to identify these people. They can give you a text-book answer, but have no ability to prove it physically.