Skip to content

Fancybox now used for image handling

Announcements
16 3 4.3k 1
  • Seeing as fancybox is such a great and efficient library, I’ve decided to implement it here. Being super lightweight, there’s absolutely zero impact to the overall speed of the Sudonix platform, I’ve included it here. In fact, it’s a fork of the same extension I wrote for the Flarum project which is still very much in use 🙂

    I’ve streamlined the code and the required functions. Images only are shown, and the function will ignore avatars and emojis etc as displaying these as part of an image carousel is pointless in my view.

    Enjoy.

  • Seeing as fancybox is such a great and efficient library, I’ve decided to implement it here. Being super lightweight, there’s absolutely zero impact to the overall speed of the Sudonix platform, I’ve included it here. In fact, it’s a fork of the same extension I wrote for the Flarum project which is still very much in use 🙂

    I’ve streamlined the code and the required functions. Images only are shown, and the function will ignore avatars and emojis etc as displaying these as part of an image carousel is pointless in my view.

    Enjoy.

    @phenomlab

    Great 😉
    Possible to have the code or a tutorial for implemented it on nodeBB ?

    because it’s very practical when users put large images for example!

  • @phenomlab

    Great 😉
    Possible to have the code or a tutorial for implemented it on nodeBB ?

    because it’s very practical when users put large images for example!

    @DownPW Sure. Here goes…

    1. In /admin/appearance/customise#custom-header add the below code
    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/@fancyapps/ui@4.0/dist/fancybox.css"/>
    <script src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/@fancyapps/ui@4.0/dist/fancybox.umd.js"></script>
    
    1. In /admin/appearance/customise#custom-js
    // Fancybox wrapper
    
    if (top.location.pathname !== '/login') {
        $(window).on('action:ajaxify.end', function (data) {
            this.$('img').not('.forum-logo').each(function () {
                // Strip out the images contained inside blockquotes as this looks nasty :)
                $('blockquote img').remove();
                Fancybox.bind(
                    'a[href*=".jpg"], a[href*=".jpeg"], a[href*=".png"], a[href*=".gif"], a[href*=".webp"]',
                    {
                        groupAll: true,
                    }
                );
            });
        });
    }
    
  • @phenomlab

    • Possible to host the script locally?
    • Possibility to have the images all the same size in the posts

    For example here, I have two images of different sizes, they should appear identically in the posts like on sudonix ?

    638a003a-c839-4890-bfe5-bf79a2b36403-image.png

  • @phenomlab

    • Possible to host the script locally?
    • Possibility to have the images all the same size in the posts

    For example here, I have two images of different sizes, they should appear identically in the posts like on sudonix ?

    638a003a-c839-4890-bfe5-bf79a2b36403-image.png

    @DownPW possible, yes, 100%. You’d just need to download the files locally and host them on your own server. Finally, you obviously need to change the target path

    The image size is simple CSS.

  • @DownPW possible, yes, 100%. You’d just need to download the files locally and host them on your own server. Finally, you obviously need to change the target path

    The image size is simple CSS.

    @phenomlab

    ha yes I have it:

    @media (min-width: 1200px) {
    .topic .posts .content .img-responsive {
        max-width: what you want %;
        width: auto;
        padding: 20px;
    }
    }
    
  • On this site, I’ve added an animation (essentially, a link underline) that meant I needed to modify the Fancybox function. The new animation I mentioned above has an annoying artefact where it also applies on images where the fancybox class exists.

    This is not surprising, as the fancybox attribute adds a a href to all img tags. Based on this, it is necessary to add a noanimate class so that the link animation is not being applied. However, this isn’t such a simple affair. Due to the Lazy Load feature that NodeBB leverages, the images aren’t in the DOM until that specific chunk of data is loaded as the user scrolls through the post. To allow for this, we need to fire an event that selects each target image extension and then appends the existing classes with noanimate as desired. For this to work, we have to create a duplicate each function that uses the preexisting hook of action: posts.loaded.

    In usual cases of an entire page load, this could be quite greedy and have a significant impact on CPU cycles. Thankfully, the cost is in fact negated by the limited amount of data being pulled in each Ajax request using the post loaded feature.

    Below is the code I developed for that

    if (top.location.pathname !== '/login') {
        $(window).on('action:posts.loaded', function(data) {
            console.log("Loaded");
            $(document).ready(function() {
                $('a').not('.forum-logo').not(".avatar").not(".emoji").not(".bmac-noanimate").each(function() {
                    $('a[href*=".jpg"], a[href*=".jpeg"], a[href*=".png"], a[href*=".gif"], a[href*=".webp"]').addClass("noanimate");
                });
            });
        });
    }
    
    if (top.location.pathname !== '/login') {
        $(document).ready(function() {
            $(window).on('action:ajaxify.end', function(data) {
                this.$('a').not('.forum-logo').not(".avatar").not(".emoji").not(".bmac-noanimate").each(function() {
                    $('a[href*=".jpg"], a[href*=".jpeg"], a[href*=".png"], a[href*=".gif"], a[href*=".webp"]').addClass("noanimate");
                    data.preventDefault()
                    // Strip out the images contained inside blockquotes as this looks nasty :)
                    $('blockquote img').remove();
                });
                Fancybox.bind(
                    'a[href*=".jpg"], a[href*=".jpeg"], a[href*=".png"], a[href*=".gif"], a[href*=".webp"]', {
                        groupAll: true,
                    }
                );
            });
        });
    }
    

    The specific CSS that defines the animated underline (which you can see for example by hovering over the usernames in each thread) is shown below - note how we exempt noanimate using the :not() class. Basically, apply this css to all a href except those that carry the appended class noanimate.

    It’s a bit of a bulldozer to break an egg, but it’s still efficient nonetheless.

    .content p a {
        position:relative;
    }
    
    .content p a:not(.noanimate):after {    
      background: none repeat scroll 0 0 transparent;
      bottom: 0;
      content: "";
      display: block;
      height: 1px;
      left: 0%;
      position: absolute;
      background: var(--link);
      transition: width 0.3s ease 0s, left 0.3s ease 0s;
      width: 0;
    }
    .content p a:hover:after { 
      width: 100%; 
      left: 0; 
    }
    
  • Thanks @phenomlab, are you still using Fancybox@4.0 on your site? I see v5.0 is available.

  • Thanks @phenomlab, are you still using Fancybox@4.0 on your site? I see v5.0 is available.

    @dave1904 Yes, currently, but will be upgrading soon!

    EDIT - I am using 5 🙂

  • Can’t see it working yet but I guess I have to rebuild/restart. Will do it later when less users are online. Already rebuilt and restarted a short time ago after deactivating the light box. 😄

    I’ll keep you updated.

  • Can’t see it working yet but I guess I have to rebuild/restart. Will do it later when less users are online. Already rebuilt and restarted a short time ago after deactivating the light box. 😄

    I’ll keep you updated.

    @dave1904 No need. Can you provide your Custom Header ?

  • @dave1904 No need. Can you provide your Custom Header ?

    @phenomlab Sure!

    <script src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/@fancyapps/ui@5.0/dist/fancybox/fancybox.umd.js"></script>
    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/@fancyapps/ui@5.0/dist/fancybox/fancybox.css"/>
    

    Edit: I should activate the header to get this working. 🤦 Thanks.

  • @phenomlab Sure!

    <script src="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/@fancyapps/ui@5.0/dist/fancybox/fancybox.umd.js"></script>
    <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cdn.jsdelivr.net/npm/@fancyapps/ui@5.0/dist/fancybox/fancybox.css"/>
    

    Edit: I should activate the header to get this working. 🤦 Thanks.

    @dave1904 Working now?

  • Yes it is. 🙂

    no more need for the light box plugin if using this solution.

  • Yes it is. 🙂

    no more need for the light box plugin if using this solution.

    @dave1904 Yes, I put this together some time ago because it’s so much simpler.

  • And it seems to be less conflicting!


Related Topics
  • Ch..ch..ch..ch..changes!

    Announcements themes layout
    16
    2
    15 Votes
    16 Posts
    3k Views
    @phenomlab of course, to be recognised is fantastic. @phenomlab said in Ch..ch..ch..ch..changes!: Sadly, no. Web crawlers and scrapers are often JS based and read text only, so styles don’t have any bearing. I’ve read mixed things about this, but no that does make sense, it was something I read a many years back when using Wordpress.
  • Planned sunset of NTFY plugin

    Pinned Announcements push nodebb ntfy
    7
    1
    8 Votes
    7 Posts
    2k Views
    I’ve noticed that I’m the only one subscribed to the push notifications on this site. If you were using NTFY previously, and have noticed that you’ve not had any alerts for a while, it’s because this feature has been disabled. You’ll now need to use the push notification to replace NTFY as mentioned in the first post.
  • ANNOUNCEMENT: Social Login Changes

    Announcements openid oauth
    4
    1
    6 Votes
    4 Posts
    2k Views
    @DownPW Always looking for ways to improve the overall experience.
  • 36 Votes
    46 Posts
    14k Views
    OGProxy : Other Memory Saturation Root Cause & Fix OGProxy was periodically saturating server RAM and swap (up to ~4 GB of arrayBuffers, swap fully consumed), causing multi-minute service degradation. After tracing through several misleading leads, the root cause was identified: OGProxy was downloading entire file-host link bodies into memory when trying to generate previews. On a file-sharing forum, links to file hosts (1fichier, etc.) are everywhere. When OGProxy received a URL like https://1fichier.com/?xxxx, it attempted to “preview” it, but that URL is a direct file download (Content-Type: application/octet-stream, Content-Length: 20.6 GB). OGProxy pulled the file into memory. Critically, neither open-graph-scraper’s downloadLimit nor an AbortController stopped this, verified by reproduction: arrayBuffers climbed ~120 MB/s past 4 GB while the abort timeout was ignored. Diagnostic path (for reference) We instrumented the process with a /debug/mem endpoint exposing process.memoryUsage() + cache size, plus a 30-second sampling trace. This let us correlate memory spikes with nginx access logs. The trace showed arrayBuffers jumping from 0 → 457 → 3669 MB in ~5 minutes, correlated via nginx log to a single GET on a 1fichier link. The cache, EventEmitter listeners, and image links were all ruled out as primary causes (cache stayed at <30 entries during the spike; heapUsed stayed low; only arrayBuffers leaked). A representative slice of the trace at the moment of the spike: 11:24:39 arrayBuffers=0 rss=161 11:25:09 arrayBuffers=457 rss=427 <- jump in one 30s sample 11:25:39 arrayBuffers=884 11:26:09 arrayBuffers=1437 ... 11:30:09 arrayBuffers=3669 No OGProxy fail log line appeared during the spike window, the offending request neither failed nor completed; it was an in-progress, never-ending download. The nginx access log for that minute pointed at the 1fichier GET. Root cause open-graph-scraper (ogs) performs its own internal fetch, and for these URLs: The downloadLimit option does not reliably abort the body download on streamed / chunked responses or on hosts that serve large application/octet-stream payloads. An AbortController passed via fetchOptions.signal does not propagate to the underlying stream read in a way that stops the transfer in time. Result: a single large file-host link could pull multiple GB into arrayBuffers before anything intervened. The fix: bounded streaming fetch The structural problem is that ogs() controls the fetch and we don’t control body consumption. The fix moves the fetch into our own code so we control every byte read: boundedFetch(url, maxBytes, timeoutMs) performs the HTTP fetch itself, then: Re-checks the final host for SSRF after redirects. Rejects any non-text/html / application/xhtml Content-Type before reading the body (aborts immediately). Reads the body chunk-by-chunk via resp.body.getReader(), tracking total bytes, and hard-aborts at 5 MB regardless of what the server claims. The retrieved HTML is then handed to ogs for parsing only: ogs({ html }). This makes the protection structural rather than cooperative: no file host can leak memory regardless of whether it honors HEAD, serves chunked, or misreports headers. Important ogs constraint You must call ogs({ html }) alone. Passing { html, url } together throws: Must specify either `url` or `html`, not both Because url is omitted, ogs cannot resolve relative og:image paths. This is fine here: the ACP client already resolves relative image paths itself (isFullPath() + host + imageUrl), so no client-side change was required. Other hardening applied in the same pass Cache: replaced memory-cache (which creates a per-entry setTimeout that retains the cached object, a secondary leak) with a plain Map using lazy expiry + a single sweep interval. Stored value is slimmed via slimResult(): only error + result + HTML truncated at </head> (preserves <title>, drops the multi-MB body and the undici response object). Cap 300 entries, 30 min TTL, 10 min negative-cache TTL. Negative cache: failed/rejected URLs are cached to prevent re-scrape hammering from the client. SSRF guards (three layers): static host/IP blocklist (private ranges, loopback, link-local, CGNAT, IPv6 ULA/link-local), DNS resolution check, and post-redirect re-validation of the final host. (Also backed at the OS level by systemd IPAddressDeny on the unit.) AbortController + clearTimeout in finally to stop the earlier MaxListenersExceededWarning listener leak on timed-out requests. nginx rate limit: limit_req_zone (10 r/s, burst 50, nodelay, returns 429) on the /ogproxy location. The API key is necessarily exposed client-side (it ships in the ACP JS), so it provides no real protection on its own; the rate limit is the actual abuse mitigation. systemd guard rail: MemoryMax=512M / MemoryHigh=400M so OGProxy can never take the whole box down again, this was the silent hero that kept the server alive throughout diagnosis. Validation Test URL Expected Result https://1fichier.com/?xxxx (20.6 GB) reject, no body read 415, arrayBuffers stays 0 Direct image (pbs.twimg.com/...jpg) reject on content-type 415 https://github.com full preview 200, OG title/image/description, HTML truncated at </head> Process idles at ~100 MB RSS; under load heapUsed oscillates and returns to baseline (no step-up accumulation). Reproduction of the bounded fetch against the 20.6 GB link, confirming zero body is pulled: arrayBuffers AVANT: 0 MB pendant: 0 MB Resultat 1fichier: REJETE: non-HTML content-type: application/octet-stream arrayBuffers APRES: 0 MB Note on dependencies Reproduced on open-graph-scraper 6.1.0 / undici 5.22.1 / Node 24. The unreliable downloadLimit behavior may be version-specific; a newer undici might handle aborts on large streams better. The bounded-fetch approach is robust regardless of the underlying library version, so it is the recommended long-term fix. Appendix A: Full server.js const express = require('express'); const ogs = require('open-graph-scraper'); const cors = require('cors'); const { URL } = require('url'); const dns = require('dns').promises; const net = require('net'); require('events').EventEmitter.defaultMaxListeners = 50; const app = express(); const port = 2000; const apiKey = process.env.OGPROXY_API_KEY || '<API_KEY>'; const REQUEST_TIMEOUT = 12000; const MAX_CONTENT_BYTES = 5 * 1024 * 1024; // 5 MB hard cap on body const CACHE_TTL_MS = 30 * 60 * 1000; const FAIL_CACHE_TTL_MS = 10 * 60 * 1000; const CACHE_MAX_ENTRIES = 300; const MAX_REDIRECTS = 3; // --- Map cache (lazy expiry, no per-entry timers) --- const cacheStore = new Map(); function cacheGet(key) { const e = cacheStore.get(key); if (!e) return null; if (Date.now() > e.expires) { cacheStore.delete(key); return null; } return e.value; } function cacheSet(key, value, ttl) { if (cacheStore.size >= CACHE_MAX_ENTRIES) { cacheStore.delete(cacheStore.keys().next().value); } cacheStore.set(key, { value, expires: Date.now() + ttl }); } setInterval(() => { const now = Date.now(); for (const [k, e] of cacheStore) if (now > e.expires) cacheStore.delete(k); }, 60 * 1000).unref(); function slimResult(results) { if (!results || typeof results !== 'object') return results; let slimHtml = ''; if (typeof results.html === 'string') { const headEnd = results.html.search(/<\/head>/i); slimHtml = headEnd !== -1 ? results.html.slice(0, headEnd + 7) : results.html.slice(0, 8192); } return { error: results.error, result: results.result, html: slimHtml }; } function isBlockedIp(ip) { if (!ip) return true; if (net.isIPv4(ip)) { const p = ip.split('.').map(Number); if (p[0] === 10) return true; if (p[0] === 127) return true; if (p[0] === 0) return true; if (p[0] === 169 && p[1] === 254) return true; if (p[0] === 192 && p[1] === 168) return true; if (p[0] === 172 && p[1] >= 16 && p[1] <= 31) return true; if (p[0] === 100 && p[1] >= 64 && p[1] <= 127) return true; return false; } if (net.isIPv6(ip)) { const v = ip.toLowerCase(); if (v === '::1') return true; if (v.startsWith('fc') || v.startsWith('fd')) return true; if (v.startsWith('fe80')) return true; if (v.startsWith('::ffff:')) return isBlockedIp(v.split(':').pop()); return false; } return true; } function isBlockedHost(hostname) { if (!hostname) return true; const h = hostname.toLowerCase(); return ( h === 'localhost' || h.endsWith('.localhost') || h.endsWith('.internal') || h.endsWith('.local') || (net.isIP(h) && isBlockedIp(h)) ); } async function resolvesToPublicIp(hostname) { try { const records = await dns.lookup(hostname, { all: true }); if (!records || records.length === 0) return false; return records.every(r => !isBlockedIp(r.address)); } catch (e) { return false; } } // Bounded streaming fetch: reads the body chunk by chunk and aborts hard at maxBytes. // Rejects non-HTML content-types before reading any body. Structural protection // against file hosts (1fichier, etc.) - independent of what the server claims. async function boundedFetch(url, maxBytes, timeoutMs) { const controller = new AbortController(); const timer = setTimeout(() => controller.abort(), timeoutMs); try { const resp = await fetch(url, { redirect: 'follow', signal: controller.signal, headers: { 'User-Agent': 'Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/126.0.0.0 Safari/537.36', 'Accept': 'text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/avif,image/webp,*/*;q=0.8', 'Accept-Language': 'fr-FR,fr;q=0.9,en;q=0.8', }, }); // Re-check final host after redirects (anti-SSRF) try { const finalHost = new URL(resp.url || url).hostname; if (isBlockedHost(finalHost) || !(await resolvesToPublicIp(finalHost))) { controller.abort(); return { ok: false, reason: 'redirect to forbidden host' }; } } catch (e) { /* ignore */ } const ctype = (resp.headers.get('content-type') || '').toLowerCase(); if (ctype && !ctype.includes('text/html') && !ctype.includes('application/xhtml')) { controller.abort(); // not HTML: read nothing return { ok: false, reason: `non-HTML content-type: ${ctype.split(';')[0]}` }; } if (!resp.body) { return { ok: false, reason: 'no response body' }; } const reader = resp.body.getReader(); const chunks = []; let total = 0; while (true) { const { done, value } = await reader.read(); if (done) break; total += value.length; if (total > maxBytes) { controller.abort(); // hard cap reached: stop downloading return { ok: false, reason: `body exceeded ${maxBytes} bytes` }; } chunks.push(value); } const html = Buffer.concat(chunks).toString('utf8'); return { ok: true, html }; } catch (e) { return { ok: false, reason: (e && e.name === 'AbortError') ? 'timeout/abort' : (e && e.message) || 'fetch error' }; } finally { clearTimeout(timer); } } app.use(cors({ origin: 'https://YOUR_DOMAIN.EXT' })); app.get('/debug/mem', (req, res) => { const m = process.memoryUsage(); res.json({ rss_mb: Math.round(m.rss / 1048576), heapUsed_mb: Math.round(m.heapUsed / 1048576), external_mb: Math.round(m.external / 1048576), arrayBuffers_mb: Math.round(m.arrayBuffers / 1048576), cache_entries: cacheStore.size, }); }); app.get('/ogproxy', async (req, res) => { let { url } = req.query; const requestApiKey = req.headers['x-api-key']; if (requestApiKey !== apiKey) return res.status(401).send('Unauthorized'); if (!url || typeof url !== 'string') return res.status(400).send('Missing URL parameter'); if (!url.startsWith('http')) { try { url = new URL(url, `${req.protocol}://${req.get('host')}`).href; } catch (e) { return res.status(400).send('Invalid URL'); } } let parsedUrl; try { parsedUrl = new URL(url); } catch (e) { console.warn(`OGProxy reject [${url}]: invalid URL`); return res.status(400).send('Invalid URL'); } if (!['http:', 'https:'].includes(parsedUrl.protocol)) { return res.status(400).send('Invalid protocol'); } if (isBlockedHost(parsedUrl.hostname)) { console.warn(`OGProxy reject [${url}]: forbidden host (static guard)`); return res.status(403).send('Forbidden host'); } const cached = cacheGet(url); if (cached) { if (cached.__ogproxyFail === true) return res.status(500).send('Error scraping Open Graph data (cached)'); return res.json(cached); } if (!(await resolvesToPublicIp(parsedUrl.hostname))) { console.warn(`OGProxy reject [${url}]: resolves to private IP / DNS fail (SSRF)`); cacheSet(url, { __ogproxyFail: true }, FAIL_CACHE_TTL_MS); return res.status(403).send('Forbidden host'); } if (cacheStore.size >= CACHE_MAX_ENTRIES) { cacheStore.delete(cacheStore.keys().next().value); } // Bounded fetch: download the body ourselves, capped at 5 MB, HTML-only. const fetched = await boundedFetch(url, MAX_CONTENT_BYTES, REQUEST_TIMEOUT); if (!fetched.ok) { console.error(`OGProxy reject [${url}]: ${fetched.reason}`); cacheSet(url, { __ogproxyFail: true }, FAIL_CACHE_TTL_MS); const code = (fetched.reason.startsWith('non-HTML') || fetched.reason.startsWith('body exceeded')) ? 415 : 500; return res.status(code).send('Unable to preview this URL'); } try { // Parse the already-fetched HTML (no second fetch). Client resolves relative image paths itself. const results = await ogs({ html: fetched.html }); const slim = slimResult(results); cacheSet(url, slim, CACHE_TTL_MS); return res.json(slim); } catch (error) { const reason = (error && error.result && error.result.error) || (error && error.message) || 'unknown'; console.error(`OGProxy fail [${url}]: ${reason}`); cacheSet(url, { __ogproxyFail: true }, FAIL_CACHE_TTL_MS); return res.status(500).send('Error scraping Open Graph data'); } }); app.listen(port, () => { console.log(`OGProxy server listening on port ${port}`); }); Note: /debug/mem is a temporary diagnostic endpoint. Remove it once the deployment is confirmed stable in production. Appendix B: nginx rate limit Zone definition, placed in /etc/nginx/conf.d/ogproxy-ratelimit.conf (included at the http level; survives vhost regeneration by the panel): # Rate limit zone for OGProxy - 10 MB shared memory (~160k IPs tracked) # 10 requests/second sustained per IP limit_req_zone $binary_remote_addr zone=ogproxy_limit:10m rate=10r/s; Application, inside the reverse-proxy location / of the OGProxy vhost: location / { limit_req zone=ogproxy_limit burst=50 nodelay; limit_req_status 429; proxy_set_header Host $host; proxy_pass http://127.0.0.1:2000; proxy_redirect off; proxy_set_header X-Forwarded-For $proxy_add_x_forwarded_for; proxy_set_header X-Api-Key $http_x_api_key; } burst=50 absorbs the legitimate burst when a user opens a link-heavy topic (the client fires many preview requests at once); sustained hammering beyond that is rejected with 429. Appendix C : systemd unit guard rails Key directives on ogproxy.service: [Service] MemoryHigh=400M MemoryMax=512M Restart=always RestartSec=3 # SSRF egress guard (OS-level backstop to the in-app checks) IPAddressAllow=127.0.0.1 127.0.0.53 127.0.0.54 IPAddressDeny=10.0.0.0/8 172.16.0.0/12 192.168.0.0/16 169.254.0.0/16 100.64.0.0/10 fc00::/7 fe80::/10 127.0.0.1 must stay allowed because nginx reverse-proxies to OGProxy over loopback; blocking all loopback breaks the nginx -> ogproxy hop (504s).
  • 2 Votes
    12 Posts
    3k Views
    @DownPW looks good to me.
  • Which Swatch are you using or prefer?

    Announcements swatch
    8
    4 Votes
    8 Posts
    2k Views
    @Sampo2910 Here’s a demo of it from their blog [image: 1665047034755-skins.gif]
  • 3 Votes
    6 Posts
    3k Views
    @phenomlab haha!! You are crazy. In a good way, of course It’s a way of saying you’re awesome !
  • New Twitter handle

    Announcements twitter
    4
    5 Votes
    4 Posts
    1k Views
    Off course