Skip to content

What’s going on with NodeBB?

Performance
20 3 5.5k 1
  • wrote on last edited by
    #1

    I used to follow this forum script very actively and with great interest, but it seems like it has lost its charm lately. What do you think? Do you believe NodeBB is heading toward the same fate as other forum scripts?

  • I used to follow this forum script very actively and with great interest, but it seems like it has lost its charm lately. What do you think? Do you believe NodeBB is heading toward the same fate as other forum scripts?

    wrote on last edited by
    #2

    @cagatay Good question. I too have noticed that things seem to be very quiet, and there seems to be less of an appetite from the developers to respond. This could be to do with workload though, and not the desire to “ignore”. My main observation would be a significant amount of effort is being placed on federation.

  • wrote on last edited by
    #3

    I also have the federation plugin or whatever it’s called, but its working principle is really not good. The World section isn’t active at all, and since I use a Turkish forum, the posts there are in English, no one understands, reads, or shows any interest.

  • I also have the federation plugin or whatever it’s called, but its working principle is really not good. The World section isn’t active at all, and since I use a Turkish forum, the posts there are in English, no one understands, reads, or shows any interest.

    wrote on last edited by
    #4

    @cagatay Yes, and that’s where federation has limits - unless the content being shared in /world matches the language of your forum, it’s useless.

  • phenomlab phenomlab marked this topic as a regular topic on
  • wrote on last edited by
    #5

    Mark, if I want to switch to another script, what forum script would you recommend?

  • Mark, if I want to switch to another script, what forum script would you recommend?

    wrote on last edited by
    #6

    @cagatay Sorry - when you say “script”, can you provide more detail?

  • wrote on last edited by
    #7

    for example xenforo, vbulletin, flarum etc.

  • for example xenforo, vbulletin, flarum etc.

    wrote on last edited by
    #8

    @cagatay That is quite the jump as importers from one forum platform to another are notoriously unreliable and could land up being quite costly if it requires managed services.

  • wrote on last edited by
    #9

    After the latest update, my entire system crashed and I’m unable to bring it back up.

  • After the latest update, my entire system crashed and I’m unable to bring it back up.

    wrote on last edited by
    #10

    @cagatay what is in the nodebb log?

  • wrote on last edited by
    #11

    070b5b55-d31b-4c03-820e-88145a1af601-image.jpeg

  • wrote on last edited by
    #12

    I downgraded the version, and now it is working. I think the issue is related to the version.

  • I downgraded the version, and now it is working. I think the issue is related to the version.

    wrote on last edited by DownPW
    #13

    @cagatay said:

    I downgraded the version, and now it is working. I think the issue is related to the version.

    Maybe yes, maybe no. it can be plugins compatibility, nodejs, npm etc.

    I don’t upgrade for now. I still waiting a little before upgrade.
    I’m on 4.10.3

  • @cagatay said:

    I downgraded the version, and now it is working. I think the issue is related to the version.

    Maybe yes, maybe no. it can be plugins compatibility, nodejs, npm etc.

    I don’t upgrade for now. I still waiting a little before upgrade.
    I’m on 4.10.3

    wrote on last edited by
    #14

    @DownPW I tend to stay at least one release behind intentionally to ensure maturity before upgrading - unless there is a good reason to do so immediately - such as identified vulnerabilities

  • wrote on last edited by DownPW
    #15

    That’s exactly our approach on PW now. Learned it the hard way , upgraded too early once or twice and paid the price. Actually sitting two releases behind at the moment, not just one. Stability over bleeding edge, unless a vulnerability forces the hand. Solid policy.

  • wrote on last edited by
    #16

    To be honest, I really regret moving to NodeBB. I should have stayed with XenForo. 😞

  • wrote on last edited by DownPW
    #17

    Honestly, I don’t regret the move at all on my side but I get that the experience can be very different depending on how comfortable you are with the technical side. XenForo is definitely more forgiving if you don’t want to deal with the server.

    One thing worth keeping in mind though: your install has some custom code on it, and need to know what it does or stay to stock nodebb witout modification

    What’s actually frustrating you the most right now? If it’s day-to-day admin stuff, there might be simpler fixes than rebuilding everything on XenForo.

  • wrote on last edited by
    #18

    I don’t want to keep worrying about whether the script will break with every update. Yes, we invested a lot of effort, yes, I have custom code, and yes, everything works well but somehow I end up facing issues after every update. And honestly, I think they have a development approach that doesn’t really listen to users. They just add or remove things based on their own ideas. The social plugins were a complete disaster

  • wrote on last edited by
    #19

    how to upgrade nodejs v20 to v22?

  • how to upgrade nodejs v20 to v22?

    wrote on last edited by
    #20

    @cagatay The most reliable way to upgrade Node.js on Ubuntu depends on how you originally installed it.

    Method 1: Using NVM (Recommended)

    If you already use Node Version Manager (NVM), upgrading is simple. NVM allows you to keep both versions and switch between them if needed.

    1. Install Node 22:
      nvm install 22
    2. Switch to Node 22:
      nvm use 22
    3. Set it as your default:
      nvm alias default 22
    4. Verify the change:
      node -v

    Method 2: Using NodeSource (PPA)

    If you installed Node.js via apt using the NodeSource repository, you need to update the repository script to point to the new version.

    1. Remove the old NodeSource list (optional but cleaner):
      sudo rm /etc/apt/sources.list.d/nodesource.list
    2. Download and run the NodeSource setup script for Node 22:
      curl -fsSL [https://deb.nodesource.com/setup_22.x](https://deb.nodesource.com/setup_22.x) | sudo -E bash -
    3. Install/Upgrade Node.js:
      sudo apt-get install -y nodejs
    4. Verify the installation:
      node -v

    Method 3: Using the ‘n’ Package

    If you have npm installed, you can use the n interactive manager.

    1. Clear the npm cache:
      sudo npm cache clean -f
    2. Install the ‘n’ helper:
      sudo npm install -g n
    3. Install Node 22:
      sudo n 22
    4. Update your shell:
      hash -r

    Troubleshooting

    • Permission Denied: If you see permission errors using Method 2 or 3, ensure you are using sudo.
    • Path Issues: If node -v still shows version 20 after upgrading via NVM, restart your terminal or run source ~/.bashrc.
    • Conflicts: Avoid mixing these methods. If you switch from apt to nvm, it is best to sudo apt remove nodejs first to avoid path conflicts.

Related Topics
  • NodeBB socket with CloudFlare

    Solved Performance socket cloudflare nodebb
    24
    3 Votes
    24 Posts
    14k Views
    DownPW
    Solved. Tuto here and here
  • SEO and Nodebb

    Performance nodebb seo
    2
    2 Votes
    2 Posts
    2k Views
    phenomlab
    @Panda It’s the best it’s ever been to be honest. I’ve used a myriad of systems in the past - most notably, WordPress, and then Flarum (which for SEO, was absolutely dire - they never even had SEO out of the box, and relied on a third party extension to do it), and NodeBB easily fares the best - see below example https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Asudonix.org&oq=site%3Asudonix.org&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i60j69i58j69i60l2.9039j0j3&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#ip=1 However, this was not without significant effort on my part once I’d migrated from COM to ORG - see below posts https://community.nodebb.org/topic/17286/google-crawl-error-after-site-migration/17?_=1688461250365 And also https://support.google.com/webmasters/thread/221027803?hl=en&msgid=221464164 It was painful to say the least - as it turns out, there was an issue in NodeBB core that prevented spiders from getting to content, which as far as I understand, is now fixed. SEO in itself is a dark art - a black box that nobody really fully understands, and it’s essentially going to boil down to one thing - “content”. Google’s algorithm for indexing has also changed dramatically over the years. They only now crawl content that has value, so if it believes that your site has nothing to offer, it will simply skip it.
  • NodeBB v3 Chat Very Slow

    Moved Performance nodebb v3 nodebb chat
    47
    11 Votes
    47 Posts
    21k Views
    phenomlab
    @DownPW Seems fine.
  • build nodebb Warning in entrypoint size limit

    Solved Performance nodebb
    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    1k Views
    phenomlab
    @eeeee they are nothing to worry about, and can be ignored.
  • How to fix size of photos & videos NodeBB

    Solved Customisation nodebb nodebb size
    7
    3 Votes
    7 Posts
    3k Views
    phenomlab
    @crazycells pleasure. Using percentages makes much more sense in this case. It’s the same argument with px vs pt vs em with fonts, margins, padding, etc., in the sense that em is generally preferred over px and pt https://stackoverflow.com/questions/609517/why-em-instead-of-px
  • Top Ranked Forums

    Chitchat nodebb top ranked
    9
    1
    3 Votes
    9 Posts
    3k Views
    phenomlab
    The real issue here is that most people consider forums to be “dead” in the sense that nobody uses them anymore, and social media groups have taken their place. Their once dominant stance in the 90’s and early 00’s will never be experienced again, but having said that, there are a number of forums that did in fact survive the social media onslaught, and still enjoy a large user base. Forums tend to be niche. One that immediately sticks out is Reddit - despite looking like it was designed in the 80s, it still has an enormous user base. Another is Stack Overflow, which needs no introduction. The key to any forum is the content it offers, and the more people whom contribute in terms of posting , the more popular and widely respected it becomes as a reliable source of information. Forums are still intensely popular with gamers, alongside those that offer tips on hacking etc.
  • NodeBB 1.19.3

    Solved Performance nodebb 1.19.3 performance
    33
    4 Votes
    33 Posts
    17k Views
    DownPW
    @phenomlab I find the problem Mark The error message indicated this path : http://localhost:4567/assets/plugins/nodebb-plugin-emoji/emoji/styles.css?v=6983dobg16u I change the path url on config.json [image: 47bacc80-f141-41e4-a261-3f8d650cc6f6-image.png] And all it’s good Weird, I didn’t have to change that path before 1.19.3 But this does not prevent the problem from a clean install with Emoji Plugin EDIT: After test, that resolv the problem installation for 1.18.x but not for 1.19.x (I have other error message when I run ./nodebb Setup For resume: NodeJS 16_x with 1.18.x is ok
  • NodeBB Design help

    Solved Customisation
    8
    3
    2 Votes
    8 Posts
    4k Views
    phenomlab
    @riekmedia I’ve applied some new CSS to your site. Can you reload the page and try again ? For the record, this is what I added #footer { background: #2d343e; border-top: 4px solid #2d343e; font-size: 0.9em; margin-top: 70px; padding: 80px 0 0; position: relative; clear: both; bottom: 0; left: 0; right: 0; z-index: 1000; margin-left: -15px; margin-right: -338px; } The /categories page seems a bit messed up, so looking at that currently EDIT - issued some override CSS in the CATEGORIES widget <!--- CSS fix for overspill on /categories page - DO NOT DELETE --> <style> #footer { margin-right: -45px; } </style> That should resolve the /categories issue.